Best Musical

1. ★ Winner
   Schmigadoon!
2. The Lost Boys
3. Titaníque
4. Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York)

1. ★ Winner
   Maybe Happy Ending
2. Buena Vista Social Club
3. Dead Outlaw
4. Death Becomes Her
5. Operation Mincemeat

1. ★ Winner
   The Outsiders
2. Hell's Kitchen
3. Illinoise
4. Suffs
5. Water for Elephants

1. ★ Winner
   Kimberly Akimbo
2. & Juliet
3. New York, New York
4. Shucked
5. Some Like It Hot

1. ★ Winner
   A Strange Loop
2. Girl from the North Country
3. MJ
4. Mr. Saturday Night
5. Paradise Square
6. Six

1. ★ Winner
   Moulin Rouge!
2. ★ Winner
   Moulin Rouge! The Musical
3. Jagged Little Pill
4. Tina

1. ★ Winner
   Hadestown
2. Ain't Too Proud
3. Beetlejuice
4. The Prom
5. Tootsie

1. ★ Winner
   The Band's Visit
2. Frozen
3. Mean Girls
4. SpongeBob SquarePants

1. ★ Winner
   Dear Evan Hansen
2. Come from Away
3. Groundhog Day
4. Natasha, Pierre & The Great Comet of 1812

1. ★ Winner
   Hamilton
2. Bright Star
3. School of Rock
4. Shuffle Along
5. Waitress

1. ★ Winner
   Fun Home

1. ★ Winner
   A Gentleman's Guide to Love & Murder
2. Aladdin

1. ★ Winner
   Kinky Boots
2. Matilda The Musical

1. ★ Winner
   Once
2. Newsies

1. ★ Winner
   The Book of Mormon

1. ★ Winner
   Memphis

1. ★ Winner
   Billy Elliot, The Musical
2. Next to Normal
3. Shrek The Musical

1. ★ Winner
   In The Heights

1. ★ Winner
   Spring Awakening

1. ★ Winner
   Jersey Boys

1. Wicked

1. ★ Winner
   Hairspray

1. Mamma Mia!

Not presented this year

1. ★ Winner
   Rent

1. Beauty and the Beast

1. Miss Saigon

1. ★ Winner
   The Phantom of the Opera
2. Into the Woods

1. ★ Winner
   Les Misérables

1. ★ Winner
   Cats

Not presented this year

1. West Side Story